Collective Investment Trusts — The Fastest Growing Investment Vehicle Within 401(k) Plans

Collective Investment Trusts — The Fastest Growing Investment Vehicle Within 401(k) Plans

Health Savings Doctors visit
This Won’t Hurt a Bit: It’s Time to Include Health Care in a Holistic Retirement Strategy
July 30, 2018
Hey Joel! – Is there regulatory guidance that would indicate whether forcing out terminated participants is favorable to keeping them in?
August 6, 2018

For almost a century, collective investment trusts (CITs) have played an important role in the markets. They were originally introduced in 1927. A 2016 study showed that they are the fastest growing investment vehicle within 401(k) plans, with 62 percent of asset managers believing their clients will shift from mutual funds to CITs.¹

For the vast majority of their existence, CITs were available only in defined benefit (DB) plans. In 1936 CIT use expanded in DB plans when Congress amended the Internal Revenue Code to provide tax-exempt (deferred) status to CITs. CITs then gained widespread adoption in the 1950s when the Federal Reserve authorized banks to pool together funds
from pensions, corporate profit-sharing plans, and stock bonus plans. The IRS also granted these plans tax-exempt status.

In the 1980s, 401(k) plans became primary retirement plans and mutual funds became the primary investment vehicle, due to daily valuation. In the 2000s, CITs gained significant traction in defined contribution (DC) plans due to increased ease of use, daily valuation, and availability. During this time CITs were also named as a type of investment that qualifies as a qualified default investment alternative (QDIA) under the Pension Protection Act of 2006.

From 2009 to 2014, the use of target-date CITs nearly doubled as a percentage of target-date assets, from 29 percent to 55 percent.³

The advantages of CITs are plentiful:
• Lower operational and marketing expenses
• A more controlled trading structure compared to mutual funds
• They’re exempt from registration with SEC, thereby avoiding costly registration fees

On the other hand, CITs are only available to qualified retirement plans, and they may have higher minimum investment requirements.

While CITs have traditionally only been available to large and mega-sized plans, continued fee litigation – as well as increased CIT transparency, reporting capabilities and enhanced awareness – has amplified the allure of CITs to plan sponsors across all plan sizes. However, CITs haven’t been widely available to all plans — until now.

Through your advisor’s strategic partnership with RPAG, a national alliance of advisors with over 35,000 plans and $350 billion in retirement plan assets collectively⁴, they can provide their clients with exclusive access to actively managed, passively managed and target date CITs, featuring top-tier asset managers⁵ at a substantially reduced cost.

For more information on CITs, please contact your Duncan Financial Group plan advisor.


¹The Cerulli Report. Cerulli Associates. 2016.

²Plan Sponsors Speak With Action. Alliance Bernstein. 2017.

³DST kasina with data from Department of Labor, Investment Company Institute.

As of 1/1/2018.

Top-tier asset managers include BlackRock, Franklin Templeton and Lord Abbett.


Article provided by RPAG; written by Alex Kahn, Investment Analyst

Alex is an investment analyst for RPAG. He consults top-tier advisors and plan sponsors across the country on investment due diligence, with a focus on target date funds. He provides pragmatic insight on market trends and developments. Alex is also an international equity analyst for the RPAG Investment Committee and advises clients on this custom target date solution. Alex graduated with a Bachelor of Arts in economics from the Wharton School of Business at the University of Pennsylvania.



The target date is the approximate date when investors plan on withdrawing their money.  Generally, the asset allocation of each fund will change on an annual basis with the asset allocation becoming more conservative as the fund nears target retirement date. The principal value of the funds is not guaranteed at any time including at and after the target date.

Collective investment trusts available only to qualified plans and governmental 457(b) plans. They are not mutual funds and are not registered with the Securities and Exchange Commission.


Stay in Touch!

Subscribe to Our Monthly Newsletter & Never Miss a Duncan Detail!

One call. One company. ALL under one roof.